Dem-on-Dem clash erupts as Stansbury bucks Heinrich on sweeping energy bill

A public Democratic family feud is breaking out inside New Mexico’s congressional delegation, with U.S. Rep. Melanie Stansbury coming out forcefully against a sweeping bipartisan permitting package negotiated and championed by fellow New Mexico Democrat U.S. Sen. Martin Heinrich.

Stansbury took to social media this week to declare herself “adamantly opposed” to the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, S. 5653, in its current form — putting her directly at odds with Heinrich, one of the four senators responsible for crafting the massive 417-page deal.

“As currently drafted, I am adamantly opposed to this bill,” Stansbury wrote, warning that it “could undermine Tribal sovereignty and consultation, protection of sacred and cultural sites, our public lands and waters, and the ability of our communities to have a say in projects that could impact them.”

She acknowledged the push to speed up major projects but argued that faster permitting cannot come at the expense of tribes, environmental protections or local input.

“We understand the urgency of expediting clean energy and critical infrastructure projects,” Stansbury wrote, “but it cannot be done at the expense of our sovereign Tribal nations, the environment, or the rights of our communities.”

She also took a swipe at the Trump administration, saying reforms should not rest on what she called its “false promises.”

The unusually sharp statement places Stansbury opposite Heinrich on one of the senator’s most significant bipartisan legislative efforts of the year.

Heinrich helped negotiate sweeping bipartisan deal

The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act was introduced Sept. 30 by Republican Sens. Shelley Moore Capito of West Virginia and Mike Lee of Utah, along with Democratic Sens. Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island and Heinrich.

Technically, Capito is the bill’s sponsor, while Heinrich, Lee and Whitehouse are original co-sponsors. But Heinrich was one of the four principal negotiators who spent more than a year working on the package.

The Bipartisan Policy Center described the legislation as the most comprehensive federal permitting reform proposal to date, saying it tackles nearly every major component of the permitting system after decades of failed reform attempts.

Heinrich has portrayed the bill as a way to build energy and transmission infrastructure more quickly while reducing costs.

“It should not take decades to build the infrastructure our country needs,” Heinrich said when the legislation was unveiled.

He said the measure would get to “yes” or “no” on projects faster while preserving environmental safeguards and “protecting the ability of Tribes to formally consult during these processes.”

That assertion now sits squarely against Stansbury’s warning that the legislation could do precisely the opposite.

Heinrich has also emphasized provisions designed to force large data centers to cover costs they impose on the electric grid rather than shifting those expenses onto residential customers.

Tribal consultation becomes flashpoint

The biggest Democratic fault line appears to involve changes to the National Historic Preservation Act.

Under current law, federal agencies generally must consult with State and Tribal Historic Preservation Officers before approving projects that could affect historic or culturally significant properties.

The Heinrich-backed legislation would impose new deadlines and narrow portions of that process.

According to the Bipartisan Policy Center’s detailed analysis, the bill would change how the geographic scope of historic-preservation reviews is determined, narrow what qualifies as an adverse effect and impose deadlines throughout consultation.

As the Bipartisan Policy Center summarized it, under the proposal “the agency, rather than the consulting parties, would decide when review is finished.”

The legislation would simultaneously authorize $200 million annually for the Historic Preservation Fund from fiscal years 2027 through 2036 and provide additional support for Tribal Historic Preservation Offices.

Stansbury breaks with Heinrich

The dispute is notable because both New Mexico Democrats generally position themselves as strong advocates of environmental protections, renewable energy and tribal consultation.

Yet on permitting reform, they now find themselves on opposite sides.

Heinrich argues that the existing federal process is so slow and unpredictable that it prevents the construction of the very clean-energy infrastructure Democrats say they want.

Stansbury, meanwhile, is warning that Congress could go too far in speeding projects along.

Her declaration that she is “adamantly opposed” to the measure represents considerably more than a minor disagreement over legislative language.

It is an open challenge to one of Heinrich’s marquee bipartisan negotiations.

And the Democratic disagreement reaches beyond New Mexico. Heinrich’s fellow Democratic negotiator Whitehouse has enthusiastically promoted the package, arguing it would help “flood the grid with clean, affordable energy.” Meanwhile, progressive and tribal groups are mobilizing against portions of it.

Bill also takes aim at data-center costs

Ironically, the legislation also contains provisions aimed directly at one of the issues that has generated substantial Democratic concern in New Mexico: enormous new data centers.

The proposal would bar utilities from shifting certain infrastructure costs associated with new data centers of 20 megawatts or greater onto other customers. States could also require data centers to provide their own generation, restrict how much electricity they draw or charge them additional amounts that could be used to lower other customers’ bills.

The broader package would also dramatically overhaul the National Environmental Policy Act, shorten litigation timelines, streamline electric transmission development, change portions of the Clean Water Act and Endangered Species Act processes, and make it more difficult for future administrations to revoke already-issued permits.

For Heinrich, those changes represent a bipartisan attempt to solve a system he says has become incapable of building infrastructure at the pace the country requires.

For Stansbury, the current bill crosses a line.

That leaves two prominent New Mexico Democrats publicly fighting over just how much environmental and permitting law Congress should rewrite in the name of faster construction — with Heinrich trying to shepherd his bipartisan deal forward and Stansbury now openly telling colleagues the legislation, as written, should not pass.

16 thoughts on “Dem-on-Dem clash erupts as Stansbury bucks Heinrich on sweeping energy bill”

  1. Well, this is interesting. Green energy is a farce, but seeing these two argue over the outcomes is amusing. Guess I’ll need to look at this bill. Can’t imagine there being much good when the push is to out law oil & gas.

  2. they are both losers. both failures. dont side with one or the other. neither one does what is best for the working taxpayers.

  3. I have read the issues pros and cons…but I must say anything that comes out of Stransbury mouth is not in the best interests of New Mexicans…she’s in for the power and status, could it be that Heinrich was bipartisan this time around, guess they do eat their own…

  4. if heinrich was involved there is fine print strangling energy production or the consumer. MORE REGULATIONS. MORE PHONY GREEN forced upon you. they will wait until AFTER the bill passes to tell you the truth about it.

  5. Our entire congressional delegation is an absolute joke. I’d call these two “Dumb & Dumber”, but that would make the other three seem intelligent, which is far from the case. I can only hope we can eventually correct this in our state.

  6. Martin Heinrich wants to shut down the oil and gas industry in New Mexico, forcing New Mexicans to buy expensive, unreliable electric cars that cost $100,000 and don’t work when it’s too hot or too cold.or going up and down mountains.

    He wants to replace power planrs with wind mills and solar panels, which will not supply enough power and will cause power shortages and blackouts.often lasting for days.

    Martin Heinrich is a far leftist gun banning Democrat who wants to restrict and ban guns in America from all law abiding American citizens,
    flase claims that this would stop crime and gangs. He wants to take your guns away leaving you and your family defenseless against criminals and gangs.

    Heinrich wants boys to play in girls sports. Why?

    Heinrich claims that there are 6 genders. Huh??

    Heinrich wants to remove the border wall and have unlimited amounts of illegals co.ing to America.
    He also wants to make all illegals American citizens with full benefits.

    Do we really want America to end up like Indua with over a billion people living in the streets, alleys, sidewalks and gutters and having to eat garbage out of dumpsters just to survive?

    Remember to vote Republican!

  7. If you trust either one of these two clowns do us all a favor stay home and don’t vote! You can see neither one is working for New Mexicans and aren’t on the same page with each other, instead catering to who lines their pocketbooks.

  8. Solar fields heat up the atmosphere. It is recoded on the internet. Look it up. When will they burn up our atmosphere to a point that human, animal and plant life feels that heat? Perhaps we already have. The last year was one of the hottest on record. Thanks to Heinrich and dumb democrats.

  9. The Native-American policy of in-your-face “poor pitiful me” status and power… is a farce in the new economy. Stansbury hasn’t done a single thing to radically improve life, particularly for the Navajo and Apache…. but, she does all this sabre rattling over the Green New Scam projects, for one purpose — to defend her $200,000 per year cushy job.
    Sorry folks. Tribal life will never change as long as these two “status quo” power wannabe’s are anywhere near the seat of government.
    All ya’all have a nice day now, ya’ hear.

  10. Russell Means said once, if you want to know how communism works, visit and live in a Reservation. No politician can cure this, only their people can. Congress wants this bill passed because what is embedded in it is more likely favorable to building data centers and the likes without the People’s consent. And the People are too stupid to think that a Bill that passes Congress is the law of the land, that they have no voice, but this is not true.

    1. Russel Means was correct. I grew up on the Rez and it destroys so many lives as the govt doles out houses that get “worn out” so people can qualify for another one. Not much maintenance is done and not much appreciation. Food handouts are also done in addition to monthly checks and SNAP bennies. Then since the non-profits destroy the market, grocery stores close and food deserts abound. I am not a fan of Means because of his occupation of Wounded Knee in the 70’s disrupting so many lives, but he is correct that the FREE mentality on the REZ destroys the work ethic and lives. Covid did not help either. Natives were paid $1000 per jab/booster, further fostering govt dependency and now all the health concerns are surfacing. A few Natives saw thru the sham, but for a community with a lot of poverty – $1000/person is a huge amount for families, and hard to turn down when it was being sold as “safe and effective”.

  11. Dems love trigger phrases , throw in some sesame street/ daycare colors or a dog with a zia bandana and the mob must agree. “racism”, as we know it was “institutionalized” by the dem lbj and his great society, add the never satisfied racist org naacp, and it will never end. “tribal soverienty”is another myth…keep them poor and on the rez…deb will be good at that !

  12. “Half truths are made to do the work of whole falsehoods,” – Shirley Maclaine

    Such is the notion we were spoon fed about closing down the San Juan Generating Station in Farmington several years back. Tree huggers and legislators agreed that the “dirty coal” plant had to be shut down in favor of clean energy. Now, every electric bill forces the customer to pay for the bond that outlived the coal plant.

    Neither Heinrich or Stansbury can run from the fact that while we’re told at election time that bonds don’t raise taxes, it’s a half truth, when you call it a RIDER instead. Look at the last page of your electric bill New Mexico. What do you see there, month after month, year after year? A damned Rider sitting above the Tax portion of your bill, like a cowboy breaking a wild horse. The Bond outlives the coal plant. Stop voting to be bondservants. The New Mexico Tax and Revenue department has issued a decree that this particular Rider must now be exposed ON YOUR BILL, and it’s about damned time your questions are aimed at the legislature, the Public Regulation Commission and feckless politicians like Heinrich and Stansbury … for the sake of the people of New Mexico … stand up and speak your peace.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top