A state district judge has ordered the city of Santa Fe to remove the wooden box and shrubbery surrounding the remnants of the Plaza obelisk within 30 days unless the city requests and secures a stay. The ruling, issued Friday by District Judge Mathew Wilson, also directs the city to either rebuild the Soldiers’ Monument within 180 days or consider alternative options, potentially prolonging the contentious debate over the monument’s fate.
The decision, which follows months of deliberation after a trial in the case, is a significant victory for Union Protectíva de Santa Fé, a historic preservation group that sued Santa Fe far-left Democrat Mayor Alan Webber and the city over the monument’s destruction during Columbus Day in 2020.
Wilson’s ruling supports the group’s claims that the obelisk is protected under the state Prehistoric and Historic Preservation Act and that any changes to the monument must adhere to the act’s guidelines. The city’s actions—including a proclamation calling for the obelisk’s removal and the construction of the large protective box—were deemed noncompliant with the act.
In his decision, Wilson stated that obscuring the obelisk violated state laws protecting historic sites. He described the monument as “an integral part of the aesthetic, character, and history of the Plaza.”
Erected in 1868, the Soldiers’ Monument honors Union soldiers from the Civil War. In 2020, Mayor Webber called for the obelisk’s removal, along with other monuments in the area, including a Kit Carson memorial (which was violently attacked) and a statue of Don Diego de Vargas (which was removed in the dead of night and stashed in a city worker’s yard until it was removed to the history museum), amid growing protests by radicalized out-of-state “activists.” Later that year, the monument was toppled during a protest, and the city’s subsequent efforts to address the issue have repeatedly faltered.
Friday’s ruling was met with approval from Union Protectíva members and others advocating for the monument’s restoration. Daniel Ortiz, founder of the Hispanic Anti-Defamation Association, expressed hope that the decision signaled “the end of cancel culture on the Plaza.”
Attorney Kenneth Stalter, who represented Union Protectíva during the trial, called the ruling “a victory for the rule of law and for the preservation of our shared history.”
“The Court’s ruling underscores that government entities must follow established legal processes when altering historic sites,” Stalter said. “The Soldiers’ Monument holds deep cultural and historical value for the Santa Fe community, and today’s judgment ensures that it will once again be visible as a central feature of the Plaza, where it belongs.”
The judge’s decision allows the city to choose from several options regarding the monument’s future.